Showing posts with label Alexandra Avenue. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Alexandra Avenue. Show all posts

Thursday, October 16, 2025

Cycle tracks - making roads for bicycle riders

Alexandra Avenue, designed by Carlo Catani was officially opened  by the Duke of Cornwall and York on May 17, 1901. It was constructed after flood mitigation works on the Yarra River and it had dedicated lanes for carriages, pedestrians, equestrians and cyclists. (1) Was this the first dedicated cycle lane in Victoria? I was hoping it was, so I could give Carlo all the credit, but it does not appear to be. It was, however, a very early cycle track, and Carlo engineered the Avenue, so he gets some credit. 


Cyclists on Alexandra Avenue, c. 1908.
Publisher: Valentine & Sons. State Library of Victoria image H96.200/612.

I looked through some of the newspapers on Trove and in the 1890s there are many reports of cycle tracks in sports grounds or show grounds, but these were training tracks or lap tracks, they weren't a track specifically for cycling for leisure in a scenic location,  or what I would consider to be the equivalent of a promenade for pedestrians rather than a running track.

Apparently the idea for a dedicated cycling track on Alexandra Avenue, which before it was officially opened was known as Taverner Boulevard, after the Minister for Public Works, John William Taverner, was suggested to Mr Taverner at a meeting in August 1896. (2) This was when he met with a deputation representing the League of Victorian Wheelmen, as well as three members of the Legislative Assembly - Mr Best, Mr Prendergast and Mr Fink.(3) The League of Victorian Wheelmen was formed in 1893 to promote and conserve the general interests of cycling. (4)

A report of the meeting was published in The Herald, under the headline Cheery Cyclists want a Track by Yarra's Banks. Mr Taverner Agrees - 
At the meeting Mr Best, M.L.A., said that the present was an opportune moment for considering the wishes of those who patronised cycling, which was not only a pastime, but a means of locomotion largely used by business men. It was felt that as the Minister was already engaged in the work of improving the Yarra, if he formed a track which could he used by cyclists he would confer a benefit on the community.

Mr S. V. Winter, as representing the League of Victorian Wheelmen, said that it was not only the young but elderly people who found this to be a healthy exercise. He hoped the Minister would see his way to have a track laid out near the city where this exhilarating exercise could be carried out. In Sturt street, Ballarat, there was a track laid down for cyclists, and in Hyde Park, London, where for a time the entrance of cyclists had been opposed, they were now permitted to ride, while in many American cities splendid tracks were laid down.

Mr Prendergast, M.L.A., impressed upon the Minister the desirability of including a provision that any track laid should be for the exclusive use of cyclists, so as to enable them to regulate the road and the traffic. By this means there would be less liability to accident. Between various cities in Europe good cycling tracks were laid down, and he was informed that on Broadway, New York, one of the most crowded thoroughfares in the world, a cycling track had been laid down.

Mr Fink, M.L.A., said that there were about 20,000 wheelmen in the colony, and the expense of the improvement work would scarcely be added to if, as had been said, it was not necessary that the track should be of asphalt. It would make the locality a fashionable promenade, and increase the value of surrounding property.

Mr Taverner said that the cause of the work was the reduction of the flood level of the Yarra, but there would be a quantity of earth to be disposed of. He had made up his mind on two points, that a footpath and a roadway along the Yarra must be constructed, and after hearing the deputation he had decided to lay down a cycle track for the exclusive use of cyclists. (Hear, hear.)  (5)

The cycling track on Alexandra Avenue, once completed, was very popular, but had a few small issues, which a letter to The Argus pointed out -
Sir, - Having seen a letter in your columns complaining of equestrians being driven off the tan riding track in Alexandra avenue by trespassing pedestrians, I wish to point out that cyclists are incommoded in the same way, and to suggest that more stringent means be adopted to secure for the different classes the use of those parts of the avenue intended for them. The cyclists and equestrians themselves might assist by making a point of attending on Sunday afternoons in force, and insisting on occupying their respective tracks till the trespassers are convinced that their own safety and convenience will be best served by conforming to the regulations.

I notice that the posts across the Prince's bridge entrance to the cycle track are too close together, as is proved by the fact that most cyclists - especially ladies - find it necessary to dismount in order to get through. It is probably possible for an expert cyclist to ride through without striking the posts, but all those whom I have seen enter have preferred dismounting to taking the chance. Another little matter I should like to mention is the need of a bicycle stable, which I should think, might easily be arranged for in connection with the tea room. Visitors are greatly encumbered in seeing the gardens by having to drag about their bicycles, and many would gladly pay a small fee to be relieved of them -Yours, &c., Safety, June 6.
(6)

What we learn from the report of the meeting with Mr Taverner, is that there was already  a dedicated bicycle track in Sturt Street in Ballarat, which may well have been the very first dedicated cycle track in Victoria.  However, I can find no other information on this track and even though the State Library of of Victoria has well over 100 historic photographs of Sturt Street on-line, I cannot find a photograph of anything resembling a track reserved for cyclists.

In October 1897, The Argus reported on a  proposed dedicated cycle track and made the claim that This, probably, is the first instance in the colony of a shire making roads for bicycle riders -
Mordialloc to Frankston. A Special Bicycle Track - At the monthly meeting of the Frankston and Hastings shire a proposal was brought forward by Councillor Sherlock which, if entertained and carried out, should make Frankston one of if not the most popular of cycling resorts. It is proposed to lay down a cycle track from Mordialloc to Frankston at a cost of from £12 to £15 a mile, the track to be made clear of all vehicular traffic. The shire engineer has been ordered to draw up an estimate of the cost for the next meeting. The proposal has met with such hearty recognition from the townspeople that £15 was immediately collected, and this is expected to be doubled in a few days, and probably as much more will be raised from visiting bicyclists. This, probably, is the first instance in the colony of a shire making roads for bicycle riders. (7)

Was the Mordialloc to Frankston track ever built?  In June 1898, the St Kilda Council considered the matter of a cycle track -
Proposed Bicycle Track - The St Kilda Council, at its meeting on Monday evening, was in receipt of a letter from Mr. B. Garnet, secretary of the League of Victorian Wheelmen, stating that the league has consented to further a movement for laying an asphalt strip 2ft. wide along the high road from St. Kilda to Brighton Esplanade, distance about 4½ miles, for the use of cyclists, providing the consent of the two councils was given. The estimated cost was £432, and the Austral Cycle Agency was prepared to bear the cost of the first mile, viz., £100. The balance would be raised by subscriptions and other wise from those interested, the league taking the initiative. The council was also asked if they "were prepared to assist the movement in any other way." On the motion of Councillor Kemp the matter was referred to the public works a committee, the city surveyor to interview Mr. Garnet in the meantime, and the latter gentleman to be informed that he was at liberty to attend the meeting of the public works committee if he so desired. (8)

Was the St Kilda to Brighton Esplanade track ever built?  In February 1900 there was another report of a cycle track -
Bicycle track to Sorrento - At a meeting of the Moorabbin council last night, the president, Cr. Penny, reported that the member of the west riding had met a representative of the Melbourne Bicycle Club, and an inspection of the proposed track, from Brighton Beach to Sandringham was made. After careful inquiry as to the requirements of the club, the committee recommended the council to sanction the making of a track inside the ti-tree reserve, the club having offered to commence the work forthwith. Cr. Barnett said he did not like to destroy the reserve, but as the track was not to exceed 6 feet in width, he 
would not oppose it. The report was adopted.
 (9)

Was the Brighton Beach to Sandringham track ever built? In October 1901, the Mornington Standard reported -
For the past week very strong winds have been experienced throughout the colony, but along the coast these have attained the strength of gales, and considerable damage and devastation has been wrought through out the peninsula by the unroofing and blowing down of buildings and trees. A large quantity of the ti-tree along the foreshore at Frankston and Mornington has fallen, and at the former town the bicycle track to Melbourne was blocked in several places through this. (10)

This seems to indicate that there was a bicycle track from Frankston to Melbourne, in which case the three tracks noted above - St Kilda to Brighton Esplanade, Brighton Beach to Sandringham and Mordialloc to Frankston may well have been constructed and collectively, these would thus constitute the second bicycle track in Victoria, after Sturt Street in Ballarat; and this means the Alexandra Avenue track is the third dedicated cycle track. 

In August 1903, the Mornington Standard published this letter to the editor -
The Cycling track - Sir, The bicycle track is almost perfect from Frankston to Melbourne, except a small piece between here and Carrum, which has been made of clay instead of gravel. When dry, it nearly jolts one to pieces, as the ridges are deep, the clay being so soft after rain the wheels sink in, and dries very rutty. Yours, &c., A Stitch in Time,  Frankston, 26/8/03. (11)

In December 1907, the same paper also had another complaint about the Carrum section of the track - 
Carrum - A special meeting of the Progressive Association is called for next Wednesday, to deal with a letter received from the secretary of the Dandenong shire, about the bicycle track between Carrum and Frankston. (12)

I am disappointed to discover that Carlo cannot claim to have established the first dedicated bicycle track in Victoria, but it doesn't diminish his glory in my eyes (as this is a blog devoted to him, I would never say anything else). As  a matter of interest, I wondered how long the bicycle track remained on Alexandra Avenue. It was still there in 1912, but it appears to have gone in 1930. In that year, there was a report in The Herald on Wattle Park and the writer, Norman Campbell, notes that -
the Chalet it is built of brick - the bricks were salvaged from the demolished chimney-stacks of the old cable tram power houses. It has handsome stonework "about it and about" -  the stones were once the boulders which defined the old cycle track in Alexandra Avenue. (13)

The removal of the bicycle track was no doubt due to the huge increase in motor cars and the need to  accommodate them on the roads. In 1919, under the headline, The Triumphal Car, The Age had these statistics on the number of registered vehicles in Victoria - 
1912 - 5,004 cars and 3,435 motor-cycles - Total 8,439
1918 - 15,158 cars and 9,928 motor-cycles - Total 25,086.
By December 1928 there were 133, 948 registered motor vehicles (cars, trucks and motor-cycles) in Victoria. (14)

Trove list - I have created  a  short list of articles on early bicycle tracks, access it here.  

Footnotes
(2) Taverner Boulevard, see references in my Trove list, here. Sir John Taverner  https://adb.anu.edu.au/biography/taverner-sir-john-william-8752
(3) The Herald, August 28, 1896, see here
(4) North Melbourne Advertiser, July 28, 1893, see here.
(5) The Herald, August 28, 1896, see here. There is another report of the meeting here - Sportsman, September 1, 1896, see here.
(6) The Argus, June 18, 1901, see here.
(7) The Argus, October 22, 1897, see here.
(8) The Argus, June 1, 1898, see here.
(9) The Age, February 6, 1900, see here.
(10) Mornington Standard, October 17, 1901, see here.
(11) Mornington Standard, August 29, 1903, see here.
(12) Mornington Standard, December 14, 1907, see here.
(13) The Herald, June 7, 1930, see here.
(14) The Argus, October 15, 1919, see here; Countryman, February 15, 1929, see here.

Thursday, March 14, 2019

Alexandra Gardens, Melbourne

Alexandra Avenue, designed by Carlo Catani,  was officially opened by the  Duke of Cornwall and York on May 17, 1901. The land adjacent to the Avenue was turned into a public park in 1904 and this park was also designed by Carlo and it was called Alexandra Gardens.  The area already a number of boat sheds for rowing clubs erected and the Army Engineers depot, which wasn't removed until 1935, so the gardens were designed behind and around these buildings.

The State Library of Victoria has a brochure from c. 1911 of a plan of the Botanic Gardens precinct gardens, including Alexandra Gardens (or Park as it was then known)


 Part of the Plan of the Botanic Gardens area showing Alexandra Park and Queen Victoria Gardens.
Botanic gardens:Photo-lithographed at the Department of Lands and Survey, Melbourne, by W.J. Butson; drawn by F.S. Hilcke, c. 1911.
State Library of Victoria - see the full plan here http://handle.slv.vic.gov.au/10381/166011

We will let a journalist from The Australasian of May 2, 1908 tell us what a delight the gardens were
One of the most, attractive sights in Melbourne just at the present time is the glorious display of flowers just across Prince's-bridge, at the entrance of the Alexandra-avenue. The roses are past their best, but the dahlias, chiefly of the cactus and decorative sections, are in their prime. Single dahlias are not appreciated by everyone, but a large yellow variety here is really a good thing. Cosmeas are in profusion; their light graceful foliage and showy blossoms contrast well with the heavier appearance of the surrounding plants. Bonfire Salvias are a blaze of dazzling scarlet S. azurea is rightly named its colour being a heavenly blue ; S. Grahami purpurata is a rosy shade of crimson. Golds and yellows are found in Rudbeckia Golden Glow and some of the dwarf Helianthuses. Cannas are a little past their prime, but Bouvardias, Lasiandras, Marguerites, and several other autumn plants ate at their best. Palms, grasses, Aralia papyrifera, Dracænas, Yuccas, and many other kinds of foliaged plants are judiciously interspersed here and there amongst the banks and beds of flowers. Signor Catani of the Public Works department deserves very great credit for the manner in which he has designed and laid out the ground. it is indeed a choice bit of landscape gardening. For many years this spot was a desolation and an eyesore; it has been converted into quite a fairy-like place, full of beautiful flowers and shrubs, rockeries, and well kept lawns, and all within a few minutes' walk of the Melbourne Town-hall. 
(Australasian May 2, 1908, see article here)

 
Princes Bridge, Melbourne.     State Library of Victoria Image H2014.1013/13

This shows some of the garden 'just across Princes Bridge', as the article above described. It is not the best photo - but I like it as it is a post card sent from Clara to Daisy - "Dear Dais - We are having a good time with my uncle, aunt and cousins. We are never home. We have  a servant coming on Saturday, so we will be able to enjoy ourselves much better. I wish you were down, from Clara"
Dais was Daisy Donaldson and the card was sent in 1905.


Even though, Carlo did deserve much credit for this dazzling array the head curator, George Cooper, deserves much credit. You can read more about George William Cooper, here. This great tribute to Mr Cooper comes from The Leader of May 4, 1912. 
The Curator, Mr G.W. Cooper; is prouder of this achievement that when he is praised for the very beautiful color displays, which are to be see at all seasons of the year in the beds and rockeries. Mr. Cooper is a son of the foreman of the Melbourne Botanic Gardens, and the results of his work, now under notice, stamp him as one of the best of the younger generation gardeners in Victoria. The all-important factor of enthusiasm is behind this excellent example of public gardening, and Mr.Cooper's untiring efforts receive full encouragement from another enthusiast, Mr. C. Catani, who as Chief Engineer of the Public Works department, is the officer responsible for the maintenance of the avenue, which ends all too abruptly at Anderson-street.




Mr G. W. Cooper in the Alexandra Gardens.
The Leader, May 4, 1912. 

One area of the gardens was the Henley Lawn where spectators by the thousands lined up to watch the annual Henley-on-Yarra rowing regatta.  The lawn was laid out by Carlo and George Cooper in Autumn 1908. You can read a history of the Henley-on Yarra here, on the Australian Henley webite, http://www.australianhenley.org/history.html


Henley, before the First World War, c.1910 - 1914. Photographer: Albert Jones. This photo was taken in the Alexandra Gardens.
State Library of Victoria H2007.130/45

One of the features of the Alexandra Gardens is the Federation Star Bed, also called the Commonwealth Star bed. It was designed by Carlo and George Cooper and on July 11, 1906 was planted out with 200 roses by the  National Rose Society. The bed consisted of a six-pointed star representing the Commonwealth with interposing circular beds signifying each State. Each State was represented by a different colour rose. Read my post on the Federation Star bed, here


Alexandra Avenue, Melbourne.
Wonderful photo of the Federation Star Bed, dated circa 1906.
State Library of Victoria  Image H96.200/607

.............................................................................................

Sources: Melbourne's Historic Public Gardens: a management and conservation guide by Rex Swanson. City of Melbourne, 1984.
Civilising the City: a history of Melbourne's Public Gardens by Georgina Whitehead (State Library of Victoria, 1997)
I have  created  a list of newspaper articles on Trove, on the Alexandra Gardens and W.G. Cooper,  you can access the list here.

Saturday, December 1, 2018

Alexandra Avenue

In  July 1891 Melbourne suffered a major flood, when the Yarra River burst its banks and flooded surrounding areas. Later in the 1890s, plans were developed to straighten out the Yarra River to help reduce this flooding.  Carlo Catani prepared the plans and the entire project was carried out under his direction and supervision.  The work included the widening of the Yarra to the 300 feet as recommended by the Flood Board of Inquiry in 1892, but from Princes Bridge to the Cremorne Railway bridge, and diverting the course of the river to remove a sharp bend. 

On July 24, 1896 Carlo Catani wrote this letter to the Inspector of General Public Works, Davidson about the proposed Yarra River works -
The question is a complex one, as it involves, besides reducing the flood level, the other equally important one of improving and straightening the bed of the Yarra for navigation and recreation purposes, and also that very important factor of forming a beautiful promenade, worthy of Melbourne, on the bank of the river, where all classes could meet.*


These were the proposed works which included removing a sharp bend and widening the river.
State Library of Victoria - click on this link to see a higher resolution image of this map http://handle.slv.vic.gov.au/10381/114207

By 1897 according to a report in The Australasian of November 13, 1897 the Avenue beside the Yarra was under construction (read the full report here)
On the south bank a boulevard is in course of formation. It is so far advanced that a steam roller is now consolidating the metal between the five lines of deciduous trees. These trees define the various avenues. The avenue, 25ft wide, next the river bank is for pedestrians; next there is a bicycle track, also 25ft wide; then a carriage way 68ft  wide; and finally a track for equestrians 33ft wide. The equestrian track was covered with tan.

Did Melbourne succeed in fulfilling Carlo's hopes of having a a beautiful promenade, worthy of Melbourne, on the bank of the river?  We will turn to The Argus of November 13, 1937 to see what they had to say on the matter. On that day the newspaper had  a feature on 'Great thoroughfares of the World' written by L.R. McLennan. You can read the full article here but here is an excerpt

Paris may boast of its Champs Elysees, Berlin of its Tiergarten and its Unter den Linden, London of its Rotton Row and Rio de Janeiro of its spacious paved thoroughfares. Melbourne, a city scarcely past its century, has in St. Kilda road and Alexandra avenue two glorious thoroughfares, which, even the most seasoned of travellers admits, would grace any of the great cities of other lands. Visitors to Melbourne have called these two outlets 'the most beautiful in the world'. 
There are many famous riverside drives oversea, but in the opinion of architectural and civic leaders in Melbourne there are few to compare with Alexandra avenue....... Alexandra avenue, whose shadowed and dappled beauty ....must stand, while the City of Melbourne endures, as a lasting monument to the genius, foresight, and pertinacity of Carlo Catani. It is to Catani, great planner for the future, a former engineer-in-chief of the Public Works Department of Victoria at a period when the city was stepping from its swaddling clothes, more than to anyone else, that the residents of Melbourne owe this sweeping boulevard of almost Elysian beauty which is now in the green prime of the springtime.

Clearly, Carlo's hopes for the beautiful promenade were realised.

The Avenue was officially opened by the Duke of Cornwall and York on May 17, 1901. The main purpose of the visit of the Duke and Duchess, who  would later become King George V and Queen Mary, was to open the first Commonwealth Parliament on May 9  at the Royal Exhibition Building in Melbourne. The Avenue was named after his mother, Queen Alexandra (I have included a short family tree of the Royal family at the end of this post) 

The State Library of Victoria has a number of photos of Alexandra Avenue - here are  a few -


Melbourne - Alexandra Avenue showing new cut for straightening the Yarra River and later the new course of the river
State Library of Victoria Image H347



Alexandra Avenue. the postcard was sent in 1906. On the right is the Temple of the Winds, designed and erected in 1901 by William Robert Guilfoyle to honour Charles Latrobe, first Governor of Victoria,  who selected the site of the Royal Botanic Gardens.  
State Library of Victoria Image H85.70/112


Alexandra Avenue. c. 1935.
State Library of Victoria Image H2000.222/20


Alexandra Avenue (Rose Series postcard)
State Library of Victoria Image H32492/1603

For those that are interested here is a short family tree of the Royal Family - Queen Victoria (1819 - 1901) - succeeded by Edward VII (1841 - 1910) who had married Princess Alexandra of Denmark (the namesake of Alexandra Parade). He was succeeded by George V (1865 - 1936), who had married Princess Mary of Teck. Their second son became George VI (1895 - 1952), who is the father of the present Queen (born in 1926).

*Catani’s letter to Inspector General of Public Works, Davidson - 24 July 1896, notes from the Alan Holgate Collection provided by Don Bartlett – VPRS 1139 Unit 2 - courtesy of Isaac Hermann.