Being born and bred on the Koo Wee Rup Swamp, I feel I always knew about Carlo as he was one of the Public Works Department engineers that worked on the drainage scheme and the town of Catani is right next door to Cora Lynn, where I grew up. This is the extended version of my history of the drainage of the Koo Wee Rup Swamp. If, by some extraordinary chance, you are not as enamoured by the history of Koo Wee Rup Swamp drainage as I am, then you can read the short version of this history on one of my other blogs, here.
I must acknowledge the books From Swampland to Farmland: a history of the Koo Wee Rup Flood Protection District by David Roberts (Rural Water Commission, 1985) and the chapter Draining the Swamp in The Good Country: Cranbourne Shire by Niel Gunson (F.W. Cheshire, 1968) in the preparation of this history.
The Koo Wee Rup Swamp originally covered about 96, 000 acres (40,000 hectares) is part of the Western Port sunkland. Very non-scientifically, the land sunk thousands of years ago between the Heath Hill fault and the Tyabb fault, and the streams that originally drained straight to the sea, such as the Cardinia, Toomuc, Deep Creek, Ararat, Bunyip and Lang Lang now descended onto the flat sections of the sunkland, flowed out over the land and created the swamp conditions.
Small
scale drainage projects on the Swamp began as early as 1857 when William Lyall (1821
- 1888) began draining parts of the Yallock
Station to drain the excess water from the Yallock Creek. In 1867, Lyall and
Archibald McMillan, owner of Caldermeade,
funded a drain through the Tobin Yallock Swamp and created a drain to give the
Lang Lang River a direct outlet to the sea. Lyall also created drainage around Harewood house (on the South Gippsland
Highway Koo Wee Rup and Tooradin).
In
1875, landowners including Duncan MacGregor (1835 - 1916), who owned Dalmore, a property of over 3,800 acres
(1,500 hectares) formed the Koo Wee Rup Swamp Drainage Committee. From 1876 this
Committee employed over 100 men and created drains that would carry the water
from the Cardinia and Toomuc Creeks to Western Port Bay at Moody’s Inlet. The
Cardinia Creek outlet was eight metres at the surface, six metres at the base
and 1.2 metres deep, so no mean feat as it was all done manually. You can still
see these drains when you travel on Manks Road, between Lea Road and Rices Road
- the five bridges you cross span the Cardinia and Toomuc Creek canals (plus a
few catch drains)
It
soon became apparent that drainage works needed to be carried out on a large
scale if the Swamp was to be drained and landowners protected from floods. The
construction of the Railways also provided a push to drain the Swamp. The
Gippsland railway line, which straddled the northern part of the Swamp, was
completed from Melbourne to Sale in 1879. The construction of the Great
Southern Railway line through the Swamp and South Gippsland, to Port Albert, began
in 1887. These lines, plus a general demand for farm land bought the Government
into the picture.
The
Chief Engineer of the Public Works Department, William Thwaites (1853 - 1907)
is almost forgotten in Swamp history, and should get more credit than he does.
Thwaites surveyed the Swamp in 1887 and his report recommended the construction
of the Bunyip Main Drain from where it entered the Swamp, in the north, to
Western Port Bay and a number of smaller side drains.
This is the Main Drain (Bunyip River) - a 1940s postcard. That would be the road bridge at the front and the rail bridge at the back
There
was a scientific background to this scheme - Lewis Ronald East, engineer
with and later Chairman of the State Rivers and Water Supply Commission
(SRWSC) , published a paper called Swamp
Reclamation in Victoria in 1935. East writes that the drainage plan was
based on the formula Q=CM3/4 - where Q was the discharge in cusecs, C a
coefficient and M the area of the area of the catchment in square miles. 50 was
adopted as the value of C for ordinary floods and 100 for extraordinary floods.
The Scheme was worked out in detail to deal with ordinary floods, but for some
unaccountable reason - possibly shortage of funds - it was recommended that the
drains be constructed in the first instance to only 1/3 of the designed
dimensions, but the reserves were to be of sufficient width to allow future
enlargement. East says that the intention of the “Swamp Board” was to merely facilitate the removal flood waters
and thus permit the use of land between floods.
A
tender for works was advertised in 1889. In spite of strikes, floods and bad
weather by March, 1893, the private contractors had constructed the 16 miles of
the drain from the Bay to the south of Bunyip and the Public Works Department
considered the Swamp was now dry enough for settlement. At one time over 500
men were employed and all the work was done by hand, using axes, shovels,
mattocks and wheel barrows.
In
spite of what seemed to be good progress - the Public Works Department had been
unhappy with the rate of progress and took over its completion in 1893 and
appointed our friend, Carlo Catani.
The
1890s was a time of economic depression in Australia and various Government
Schemes were implemented to provide employment and to stop the drift of the
unemployed to the city. One of these schemes was the Village Settlement Scheme.
The aim was for the settlers to find employment outside the city and to boost
their income from the sale of produce from their farms. It was in this context
that Catani implemented the Village Settlement Scheme on the swamp. Under this
Scheme, all workers had to be married, accept up to a 20 acre (8 hectares) block and
spend a fortnight working on the drains for wages and a fortnight improving
their block and maintaining adjoining drains. The villages were Koo Wee Rup,
Five Mile, Vervale, Iona and Yallock. The first 103 blocks under this scheme were allocated in April 1893.
Many of the settlers were unused to farming and hard physical labour, others were deterred by floods and ironically a drought that caused a bushfire. Many also relied on the wages they received for working on the drains, however this work finished in November 1897, so unless they could find other employment, or their farm was enormously successful they chose (or were forced by circumstance) to leave the Swamp. The Village Settlement Scheme on the Swamp was abandoned in 1899 and the land was opened for selection in the regular way.
My great grandfather, James Rouse, a
widower, arrived on the Swamp with his nine year old son Joe, in 1903. James,
who had been a market gardener in England, was part of a second wave of
settlers who were granted land as they had previous farming experience. By 1904, over 2,000 people including 1,400
children lived on the Swamp. By the 1920s, the area was producing one quarter
of Victorian potatoes and was also a major producer of dairy products. In fact,
as we know, Koo Wee Rup remains an important potato growing area and the
importance of the potato was celebrated by the Annual Potato Festival during
the 1970s and 1980s. Today, 93% of all Australian asparagus is produced on the Koo
Wee Rup Swamp.
The
existing drainage works that we see on the Swamp today are really the result of
a reaction to various floods. As East wrote in 1935 it was soon evident that the drainage provision made was quite
inadequate. There was a flood in
1893 and according to East the drains were enlarged by at least 50% in 1895 and
then enlarged again in 1902, the catalyst being the 1901 flood. The 1902 work had the objective to remove all
floodwaters from a maximum flood within three days
There
were some additional drains created in 1911 and by 1912 East says that the
drainage scheme had cost £234,000 and the Government had recouped only
£188,000. There were arguments over who should fund the scheme - many land
owners were opposed to being charged for any work and it was not until after
more floods in 1916 and 1917 they agreed in principle to an annual flood
protection charge and the ‘Lower Koo Wee Rup flood protection district’ came
into being.
The
State Rivers scheme provided for substantial remodelling and enlargement of
existing drains, new channels and additional drains next to the Main Drain to
take the water from the converging side drains. Other work carried out at this
time included giving the Lang Lang River a straight channel to the bay and at
the western end of Swamp tapping the Deep Creek into the Toomuc Drain created
in 1876.
Before
I go on to the devastating 1934 flood I am going to tell you about the LubeckerSteam dredge. Apparently Catani was interested in using machines on the Swamp
in the 1890, but as this was a time of depression the Public Works Department
felt that this would take away jobs so it wasn’t until 1913 that Catani could
import his first dredge. It was the Lubecker Bucket Dredge, costing £4,716 which
arrived in 1913 and started work on the Lang Lang River. When it finished there
in 1916 it started on the Koo Wee Rup Swamp on the Main
Drain, Cardinia Creek and the Yallock Drain. It weighed 80 tons and had a capacity
of 80 cubic metres per hour. A labourer at the time dug about 8 cubic metres
per day. It had nearly completed its useful life in 1935 when East wrote his
report.
The now demolished Memorial Hall at Koo Wee Rup in the 1934 flood
Koo Wee Rup Swamp Historical Society photo
None
of the existing works could prepare the swamp for the 1934 flood. In
October of that year, Koo Wee Rup received over twice its average rain fall.
November also had well above average rainfall and heavy rain fell on December 1
across the State. This rainfall caused a flood of over 100,000 megalitres or
40,000 cusecs (cubic feet per second) per day. This was only an estimate
because all the gauges were washed away. The entire Swamp was inundated; water
was over 6 feet (2 metres) deep in the town of Koo Wee Rup, exacerbated by the
fact that the railway embankment held the water in the town; my grandparents
house at Cora Lynn had 3½ feet of water through it and according to family
legend they spent three days in the roof with a nine, five, three year old and
my father who was one at the time. Over a thousand people were left homeless.
This flood also affected other parts of the State, including Melbourne.
There
was outrage after the 1934 flood, directed at the SRWSC and it was even worse
when another flood, of about 25,000 megalitres (10,000 cusecs) hit in April,
1935. After this flood, 100 men were employed to enlarge the drains.
As
a result of the 1934 flood, the SRWC worked on new drainage plans for the Swamp
and these plans became known as the Lupson Report after the complier, E.J
Lupson, an Engineer. A Royal Commission was also established in 1936. Its role
was to investigate the operation of the SRWSC. The Royal Commission report was
critical of the SRWSC’s operation in the Koo Wee Rup Flood Protection District
in a number of areas. It ordered that
new plans for drainage improvements needed to be established and presented to
an independent authority. Mr E. G Richie was appointed as the independent
authority. The Richie Report essentially considered that the Lupson Report was ‘sound
and well considered’ and should be implemented. Work had just begun on these
recommendations when the 1937 flood hit the area. The 1937 flood hit Koo Wee
Rup on October 18 and water
was two feet (60cm) deep in Rossiter Road and Station Street. The flood peaked
at 20,000 cusecs (50,000 megalitres) about half the 1934 flood volume.
The
main recommendation of the Lupson / Ritchie report was the construction of the
Yallock outfall drain from Cora Lynn, cutting across to Bayles and then
essentially following the line of the existing Yallock Creek to Western Port
Bay. The aim was to take any flood water directly to the sea so the Main Drain
could cope with the remaining water. The Yallock outfall drain was started in 1939
but the works were put on hold during World War Two and not completed until
1956-57. The Yallock outfall drain had been originally designed using the
existing farm land as a spillway ie the Main Drain would overflow onto existing
farmland and then find its own way to the Yallock outfall drain. Local farmers
were unhappy at this, as the total designated spillway area was 275 acres (110
hectares). They suggested a spillway or ford be constructed at Cora Lynn so the
flood water would divert to the outfall drain over the spillway. The spillway
was finally constructed in 1962.
There
is on-going work on the Main Drain all the time - recreation of levee banks,
removal of vegetation etc but the opening of the spillway was basically the
last major engineering works to happen on the Swamp.
Today
we look at Swamps as wetlands, worthy of preservation, but we need to look at
the drainage of the Swamp in the context of the times. Koo Wee Rup was only one
of many swamps drained around this time; others include the Carrum Swamp and
the Moe Swamp. To the people at the time the drainage works were an example of
Victorian engineering skills and turned what was perceived as useless land into
productive land and removed a barrier to the development of other areas in
Gippsland.
Construction of the Spillway at Cora Lynn, October 1962 - the Main Drain is on the right, separated by a soon to be removed levee bank from the spillway which is ironically underwater, due to a flood. Photo: Rouse family collection
